ABSTRACT

Ramjee, Gita, Neetha S. Morar, Sarah Braunstein, Barbara Friedland, Heidi Jones, and Janneke van de Wijgert. "Acceptability of Carraguard, a candidate microbicide and methyl cellulose placebo vaginal gels among HIV-positive women and men in Durban, South Africa," AIDS Research and Therapy 4: 20. (offsite link) 

Background and methods
When on the market, microbicides are likely to be used by individuals who do not know their HIV status. Hence, assessment of safety and acceptability among HIV-positive men and women is important. Acceptability of Carraguard®, the Population Council's lead microbicide candidate was assessed in a Phase I safety study among healthy HIV-positive sexually abstinent women and men, and sexually active women (20 per group), in Durban, South Africa. Participants were randomized to use Carraguard gel, placebo gel, or no product. All women in the gel arms applied 4 ml gel vaginally every evening for 14 intermenstrual days (women in the sexually active group inserted gel within 1 hour prior to sex on days when sex occurred), and sexually abstinent men applied gel directly to the penis every evening for 7 days. Acceptability was assessed by face-to-face structured questionnaires and semi-structured in-depth interviews with all participants. Gel use questions were applicable to participants in the gel arms only (13 sexually abstinent women, 14 sexually active women, and 13 abstinent men).

Results
Overall, 93 percent of the women liked the study gel (Carraguard or placebo) very much, 4 percent disliked it somewhat, and 4 percent were neutral. Fifteen percent of men and women disliked the gel's color, smell, or packaging. Most women and men reported never experiencing pain or irritation during or after gel application. Although over two-thirds of the women preferred some lubrication during sex, some of the women felt that the gel was frequently too wet. Twenty-one percent of women and 42 percent of men said they felt covert use of a microbicide would be acceptable. Over 60 percent of women and men would prefer to use a microbicide alone instead of using it with a condom.

Conclusion
Acceptability of Carraguard among HIV-positive women and men in Durban was good. The wetness experienced by the women may be attributed to the delivery of gel volume. The applicator was designed to deliver 4 mls whereas in fact between 4 ml to 5 mls were actually dispensed. Condom migration in the event of a partially effective product is of concern.

Return to Microbicides Publications/Resources page

---